Spy Wednesday
Spoken Gospel podcast with a photo of David and Seth

Spy Wednesday

About This Episode

1600 years ago Christians began calling the last days of Jesus’ life “Holy Week.” Seth and David talk about the sober choice Spy Wednesday, the day Jesus was covered in an expensive perfume by Mary and betrayed by Judas, offers us.

Listen NowRead Show Notes

Listen On

Apple PodcastsYoutubeSpotify
Text Link

Two Responses to a King Who Must Die

Show Notes

In this Holy Week special episode, David and Seth explore the events traditionally remembered on Holy Wednesday—also known as Spy Wednesday. This day marks a turning point in the Gospel narrative where two radically different responses to Jesus come into sharp focus: Mary's extravagant anointing and Judas's decision to betray.

The Claims That Demand a Response

Throughout the first days of Holy Week, Jesus made increasingly bold claims about his identity and mission. He entered Jerusalem as a rival king to Caesar, cleansed the temple as one with authority over Israel's worship, and called his followers to join him in a revolution that would overthrow the religious establishment. By Wednesday, everyone who had been listening was forced to make a decision. The question was no longer whether Jesus was controversial—it was whether his message was offensive enough to reject or compelling enough to embrace completely. Mary and Judas represent the two possible answers to that question, and their contrasting actions reveal what it truly means to respond to Jesus.

Mary's Extravagant Preparation

In the Gospel of John, Mary's anointing of Jesus takes place after she has witnessed her brother Lazarus rise from the dead. At a celebratory meal with her family, Mary does something unexpected and socially awkward—she breaks open a jar of perfume worth nearly a year's wages, roughly 300 pieces of silver, and pours it over Jesus's head and feet. This was not a common Jewish custom. It was extravagant, out of place, and made everyone at the table uncomfortable.

John tells us that Mary did this to prepare Jesus for burial. Normally, anointing with oils and spices was performed after death to mask the smell of decomposition during the mourning period. But Mary performs this embalming ritual on a living man, at a dinner table, surrounded by guests. She has heard Jesus declare that he is the resurrection and the life (John 11:25). She has seen that declaration vindicated in her brother's return from the grave. And she has come to understand something profound: if Jesus is going to bring life to all people the way he brought life to Lazarus, he must first die. Her anointing is an act of faith—a declaration that she believes Jesus's death will accomplish something worth everything she owns.

Caiaphas and the Plot to Kill Jesus

At the same moment Mary is anointing Jesus in Bethany, the scene shifts to the temple courts where the Jewish Sanhedrin is meeting. Caiaphas the high priest, along with the religious leaders, are consumed with anxiety about Jesus. They fear that his claims to kingship will provoke Rome into crushing whatever limited autonomy they still possess. A Jewish rebellion, even a perceived one, would bring the full weight of Roman military power down on their nation.

Their solution is brutally pragmatic: kill Jesus before Rome has a reason to act. Caiaphas famously argues that it is better for one man to die than for the whole nation to perish (John 11:50). What makes this parallel so striking is that both Mary and Caiaphas share the same goal—saving God's people—and both believe Jesus must die to accomplish it. The difference lies entirely in what that death means. For Caiaphas, Jesus's death is the elimination of a threat. For Mary, it is the inauguration of salvation.

Judas Chooses His Side

Judas witnesses Mary's extravagant sacrifice and is offended by it, along with the other disciples. He objects that the perfume should have been sold and the money given to the poor. But Jesus defends Mary with the famous words, "The poor you will always have with you, but you will not always have me" (John 12:8). This statement is not a dismissal of caring for the poor. It is a declaration of priority—Mary has recognized that Jesus's presence in this moment, and his coming death, is worth more than any other investment she could make. She has chosen the better thing.

John also reveals that Judas had been stealing from the disciples' money bag, which adds another layer to his objection. When he realizes he can no longer profit from following Jesus, he goes to the religious leaders and offers to betray him for 30 pieces of silver—exactly one-tenth of what Mary had just poured out in worship. This detail echoes Zechariah's prophecy (Zechariah 11:12-13), adding to the mounting evidence that Jesus's death, though orchestrated by human schemes, is unfolding according to God's ancient plan. Judas's betrayal is not just a financial transaction; it is a theological choice. He sides with the religious establishment against the one he had followed for years.

The Question Holy Wednesday Asks

What makes Holy Wednesday unique among the days of Holy Week is that it does not simply announce good news—it poses a question. Everyone in the story agrees that Jesus must die. That much is certain. But the meaning of his death is what divides them. For Caiaphas, Jesus's death is a political necessity. For Judas, it is a final opportunity to profit. For Mary, it is the means by which God will save his people.

On this side of the cross, Jesus's death is no longer a future event but a historical fact. The question remains the same: What does it mean to you? Is it simply a tragic story of a good man crushed by a corrupt system? Or is it what Mary believed it to be—the salvation of all who trust in him? Holy Wednesday confronts us with a choice. Will we respond to Jesus's claims with the extravagance of Mary, giving everything we have to honor the one who will die and rise again? Or will we find a way to profit from him, betray him, or silence him to preserve our own comfort and security? The answer to that question determines whether we stand with Mary at the feet of a king preparing for burial, or with Judas walking toward the temple to collect our 30 pieces of silver.

Transcript

Related Resources

Introduction to

Watch Video

We have not recorded any devotionals for yet.

Donate now

Ready to study a different book?

GO TO LIBRARY
No items found.
Free videos sent straight to your inbox.