Jonah 3: God Repents of Evil
Spoken Gospel podcast with a photo of David and Seth

Jonah 3: God Repents of Evil

About This Episode

Reluctantly, Jonah finally delivers God's message to Ninevah, and both Ninevah and God repent of evil. It's offensive language to describe God's offensive mercy. Seth and David talk about the way God overturns not only Jonah's prophecy but our expectations about who God's mercy can be extended to.

Text Link

God Repents of Evil: How Jonah 3 Overturns Everything You Expect

Show Notes

David and Seth continue their walk through the book of Jonah, arriving at chapter 3, where the theme of overturning reaches its highest point. What happens when a reluctant prophet delivers the worst sermon in biblical history to the most violent empire on earth? The answer subverts every expectation and cuts to the heart of what the Gospel means for the worst of the worst.

From the Belly of One Beast to Another

Jonah has just been vomited onto the shore, and God calls him a second time to go to Nineveh, mirroring the call from chapter 1. But Jonah's reluctance hasn't faded. The fish carried him back toward Nineveh against his will, and there's good reason to believe Jonah thought he was being returned to the temple in Jerusalem, not dropped at the doorstep of Israel's greatest enemy. His prayer in chapter 2 never mentions Nineveh. He talks about gazing once more on God's holy temple. Imagine his surprise when the fish spits him out on Assyrian soil and God tells him, again, to do the thing he tried to run from.

The text draws a deliberate parallel between the fish and the city. Jonah spent three days in the belly of the fish, and Nineveh is described as three days' journey in breadth (Jonah 3:3). Throughout the prophets, in Amos, Jeremiah, and even 2 Chronicles, exile is described as being swallowed by a sea monster. Jonah's life is a living picture of Israel's exile. He moves from one belly of the beast to another. And this matters because the original audience, Jews living in exile, would have recognized their own situation. They too were living inside the belly of the beast. So the question Jonah 3 poses to them is pointed: What do you do when you're surrounded by your oppressors? The answer the text offers is scandalous. You preach salvation to them.

The Worst Sermon Ever Preached

Jonah walks one day into the city and delivers what might be the most half-hearted prophetic message in Scripture: "Yet forty days, and Nineveh shall be overthrown" (Jonah 3:4). That's it. Five words in Hebrew. No call to repentance. No call to action. No mention of God. He doesn't even give them Yahweh's name. When Jonah spoke to the sailors in chapter 1, he at least identified the God of heaven. Here, he withholds everything. He doesn't want to extend the covenant to Assyria, so he gives them the bare minimum, a death sentence with no return address.

This is a total subversion of the prophetic genre. Normally, readers hear God's message, then the prophet's delivery of it, and sometimes the audience's response. In Jonah, we never hear what God actually told Jonah to say. We only get Jonah's stripped-down version. And the word he chooses, "overthrown," is loaded with meaning. It's the same word used to describe what happened to Sodom and Gomorrah when fire fell from heaven (Genesis 19:25). Jonah likely picked it on purpose. He wanted another Sodom and Gomorrah. He wanted Assyria to burn. But the word is what scholars call a contronym, a word that carries opposite meanings. It can mean destroyed, but it can also mean transformed or changed for the better. In Deuteronomy 23:5, the same word describes how God overturned Balaam's curse against Israel into a blessing. Jonah intended the word as a death sentence. God intended it as a promise of transformation.

A Revival No One Expected

Against every expectation, the people of Nineveh believe God. They call for a fast and put on sackcloth, from the greatest to the least (Jonah 3:5). This grassroots movement reaches the king, and what the king does stands in sharp contrast to everything Jonah has done throughout the book. Jonah went down, down to Joppa, down into the ship, down into the sea, down into the fish. But the king of Nineveh? He arose from his throne (Jonah 3:6). He calls for a nationwide fast, commands every person and even all livestock to be covered in sackcloth, and pleads, "Who knows? God may turn and relent and turn from his fierce anger, so that we may not perish" (Jonah 3:9).

The detail about the livestock wearing sackcloth is strange but deliberate. In a book as sparsely worded as Jonah, the extended description of Nineveh's repentance serves a pointed purpose. It mirrors the lengthy description of Jonah's disobedience in chapter 1. Where Jonah was passive, reluctant, and defiant, Nineveh is speedy, ready, and extreme in obedience. The lavishness of the repentance also exposes how little information Jonah gave them. The king says "who knows?" because he genuinely doesn't know what God wants. Jonah withheld the prophet's essential role: telling people what God desires. So Nineveh does everything they possibly can to placate a God whose name they were never given. They're groping toward atonement without a guide. And this becomes an indictment not just of Jonah but of Israel in exile. The enemies of God's people repented more dramatically than God's own people ever did, and they did it with far less information.

The Overturning of the Cross

The ironic overturning at work in Jonah 3 points directly to the cross of Jesus. The powers of evil believed that putting the Son of God to death would be their ultimate victory. If they had known that crucifixion was the path to their defeat, they never would have done it (1 Corinthians 2:8). Death itself was overturned, transformed from the final word into the doorway to life for the world. Even the sign nailed above Jesus' head, "Jesus, King of the Jews," was meant as mockery. Rome intended it as a display of dominance over a conquered people. But that sarcastic label became the truest proclamation in history. Jesus is King of the Jews, from the line of David, and through his death and resurrection, he reigns as King over every nation.

The same dynamic plays out in Jonah's sermon. Jonah intended his words as a curse. God fulfilled them as a blessing. If Jonah had known his fire-and-brimstone message would become the means of Nineveh's transformation, he never would have preached it. Just as the powers would not have crucified Jesus if they had known it would be their undoing. God specializes in taking words and events that look like defeat and overturning them into instruments of redemption. The assumptions we make about what is possible, the fates we assign to others and ourselves, God has the scandalous mercy to overturn for the better.

When God Repents of His Evil

The most provocative claim in Jonah 3 is found in the language the text uses to describe God's response to Nineveh's repentance. When the people repent of their "evil" (ra in Hebrew), God repents of his "evil" (the same word, ra). When the people turn from their ra, God turns from his ra (Jonah 3:10). In English, we have separate words for moral evil and unfortunate circumstances, "evil" versus "bad." But Hebrew has only one word for both. So the text deliberately uses the same term for Nineveh's wickedness and for God's planned disaster, binding them together. This is consistent with how God describes himself throughout Scripture. In Jeremiah 18, God says that if a nation he has warned repents of its evil, he will repent and not inflict the disaster he had planned.

This is what makes the Gospel so offensive to Jonah, and to us. It is part of the Gospel message to say that God has ra planned for the world, that judgment is coming. But when that message reaches people and they repent of their ra, God repents of his. Bad news becomes good news. And Jonah cannot stomach it. He will call God evil for extending mercy to Assyria, because he believes people like that, oppressors, torturers, empire builders, should never receive the mercy of the covenant. We feel the same instinct. We don't want to see history's worst villains welcomed into heaven. But the book of Jonah forces an uncomfortable connection: if we refuse mercy to the people we consider evil while refusing to call ourselves evil, we become Jonah. We become hypocrites who want justice for others and grace for ourselves. It is only when we recognize that we too are the ra people, the ones God had every right to judge, that we discover we are also the ones God has chosen to overturn. That recognition is where mercy lives, and it is the Gospel that Jonah tried so hard not to preach.

Transcript

Related Resources

Listen to the Jonah 1: Jonah's Not About A Fish podcast

Listen Now

Listen to the Jonah 2: A Prayer from the Deep podcast

Listen Now

Listen to the Jonah 3: God Repents of Evil podcast

Listen Now

Listen to the Jonah 4: Is God's Mercy Evil? podcast

Listen Now

Listen to the What We Missed in Jonah podcast

Listen Now
Free videos sent straight to your inbox.