Deuteronomy 5-6: The Ten Commandments (Again?)
Spoken Gospel podcast with a photo of David and Seth

Deuteronomy 5-6: The Ten Commandments (Again?)

About This Episode

In this passage, Moses recites the Ten Commandments for the second time. Is this just repetition, or is something deeper happening here? Why does God give us commands? How can we keep God's commands? What does it mean to write God's commands on our hearts? What is the connection between our righteousness and obeying the Law?

Text Link

Deuteronomy 5–6: The Ten Commandments (Again)

Show Notes

David Bowden and Seth Stewart open this episode of the Spoken Gospel podcast from opposite coasts—David in California and Seth in Kansas—ready to dig into Deuteronomy 5 and 6. The conversation kicks off with a playful exchange about déjà vu, which turns out to be the perfect entry point into the big question driving this episode: Why does the Bible repeat the Ten Commandments almost word for word?

Why Does God Repeat the Ten Commandments?

The repetition of the Ten Commandments in Deuteronomy 5 is one of the rare instances in Scripture where an event is retold with this level of detail. The only comparable parallel is the four Gospel accounts of the life, death, burial, and resurrection of Jesus. That connection is not accidental. The rescue of Israel from Egypt functions as the gospel story of the Old Testament—God delivering his people from physical enslavement—just as the death and resurrection of Jesus delivers us from spiritual enslavement. Both stories are repeated because they are God's revelations that save us from evil.

The reason for the repetition in Deuteronomy is that the original generation who heard the commandments at Sinai died in the wilderness throughout the book of Numbers. Moses makes this explicit in Deuteronomy 5:3 when he says the covenant was not made with "our fathers" but with the current generation—people who were babies, young children, and teenagers when God first spoke from the mountain. They would not have grasped the gravity of that moment. So the commandments are being repeated because this younger generation is the intended recipient of the covenant. It is their initiation into the covenant as they prepare to enter the Promised Land.

The passage also carries a visceral, generational weight. Deuteronomy 5:9 warns that the consequences of disobedience fall on the third and fourth generations. A parent standing in that crowd, perhaps someone who was 19 years old when the wilderness wandering began and is now nearly 60, could literally look at their grown children and grandchildren and feel the stakes of obedience and forgetfulness in their bones. They had watched their own parents die in the wilderness. They did not want that fate for their descendants.

What Changed Between Exodus 20 and Deuteronomy 5

Rather than walking through each commandment again, the episode focuses on the differences between the Exodus 20 version and the Deuteronomy 5 version. The most striking change is in the fourth commandment, the Sabbath. In Exodus 20:11, the motivation for keeping the Sabbath is grounded in creation: God made the heavens and the earth in six days and rested on the seventh. In Deuteronomy 5:15, the motivation shifts to deliverance: "You shall remember that you were a slave in the land of Egypt, and the Lord God brought you out from there with a mighty hand and an outstretched arm. Therefore the Lord your God commands you to keep the Sabbath day."

These are not contradictory reasons but complementary ones. The first motivation points forward to Eden—press on toward the rest God designed from the beginning. The second motivation points backward to rescue—you used to be slaves who never had a day off, but now you are free, so rest and remember that freedom. Rather than needing to choose between the two, the episode suggests we should marvel that God is gracious enough to give us two motivations for one command. For those who trust in Jesus, the Gospel deepens both motivations. Jesus has earned our acceptance, approval, and righteousness through his life, death, and resurrection. We do not have to run at a frenetic pace trying to earn the approval of God, our families, our careers, or even the numbing comfort of entertainment. We can rest for the first time because we are approved and accepted by the God of the universe.

The fifth commandment also receives an addition. In Exodus 20, the promise attached to honoring your father and mother is simply long life in the land. In Deuteronomy 5:16, it expands: "that it may go well with you in the land." This doubling of promise points toward what life in the new creation will look like—family relationships healed, perfect forgiveness for past wrongs, peace between parents and children. The coveting commandment is also restructured. In Deuteronomy, the prohibition against coveting your neighbor's wife is separated from the prohibition against coveting his property, which scholars note may be an intentional clarification that wives are not to be understood as possessions.

The Terrifying Power of God's Voice

After the commandments are restated, Moses retells what happened after God spoke. In Deuteronomy 5:24–26, the people of Israel recognized something terrifying: they had heard the voice of God and were still alive. They understood implicitly that a sinful human being in the presence of a holy God should not survive that encounter. God confirmed their instinct—they were right to be afraid.

This stands in sharp contrast to how many people casually think about hearing from God today. There is an entire cultural expectation that God should speak to us constantly and comfortably. But throughout the Old Testament, the voice of God carries the weight of judgment. Isaiah 11:4 says God will strike the earth with the rod of his mouth. The voice of God is not merely comforting communication—it is the verbal issuing of an absolute standard that reveals where everyone stands. The analogy of a police officer is helpful here: even when you are doing nothing wrong, the mere presence of someone who embodies the law makes you nervous.

When the Ten Commandments were spoken over Israel, the people knew they had not lived up to the standard. They should have died. And yet they did not, because God showed grace and long-suffering even in the moment of judgment. This tension runs all the way through Scripture to Revelation 19:15, where Jesus returns and a sword comes out of his mouth. If all Jesus did at his return was speak the Ten Commandments, every person would know in that instant whether they were guilty—and everyone would be. But for those who have placed their trust in Jesus, that sword will not pierce them. It will vindicate them. It will cut Sin off of them. As Jesus said in John 6:63, "The words that I have spoken to you are spirit and life." Out of the same mouth comes both judgment and life, both death and resurrection.

The Shema and the Heart of Deuteronomy

Chapter 6 introduces one of the most famous passages in all of Scripture—the Shema: "Hear, O Israel, the Lord our God, the Lord is one. You shall love the Lord your God with all your heart and with all your soul and with all your might" (Deuteronomy 6:4–5). This prayer became the foundational creed of Judaism and is still recited by Jews around the world today.

The Hebrew word translated "one" does not simply mean "alone" or "singular." It carries the connotation of unity—the same word used in Genesis 2 when Adam and Eve become "one flesh." A husband and wife are not one person, but they are one unit. This means the Shema actually provides a framework for understanding the trinity rather than undermining it. If God were simply singular, there would be no need to assert his oneness. But the Torah has already introduced the word of God, the spirit of God, multiple divine names and attributes, and even a heavenly council. In the ancient polytheistic world Israel came from in Egypt, the temptation was to assign each attribute of God to a separate deity. The Shema insists that all of these attributes belong to one unified God.

The Shema also captures the moral theology of the entire book of Deuteronomy: hear, love, obey. You hear from God what he has done for you and what he requires. That hearing creates love in your heart. That love leads to obedience. The passage goes on to instruct parents to write these commands everywhere—on the doorposts of their houses, on their foreheads, on their hands—and to teach them diligently to their children. Orthodox Jews still practice this literally through the mezuzah on the doorpost and phylacteries worn during prayer. But the goal was never merely external. Deuteronomy 6:6 says, "These words that I command you today shall be on your heart." The external repetition was meant to work its way inward. And yet later in the book, Moses will reveal that Israel's heart is hard and uncircumcised. The prophets Ezekiel and Jeremiah will pick up this thread and declare that what Israel truly needs is a new heart—one on which God himself writes his law.

The Danger of Forgetting in a Land of Plenty

The real threat in Deuteronomy 6 is not primarily disobedience but forgetfulness. Moses warns that when Israel enters the Promised Land and inherits great cities they did not build, houses full of good things they did not fill, cisterns they did not dig, and vineyards they did not plant, they will be tempted to forget the God who provided it all (Deuteronomy 6:10–12). Comfort and abundance would make them feel self-sufficient, as though they no longer needed God.

This warning resonates deeply for anyone living in a Western context where basic needs are easily met. It also connects to Jesus' encounter with the rich young ruler, who had checked off every moral box and had all his material needs covered, so he felt no need for a traveling teacher from Nazareth. Jesus cut to the heart of the issue by telling him to sell everything—because only then would the young man feel his dependence on God again. Proverbs 30 echoes the same concern: "Give me neither poverty nor riches, lest I forget you." The gaining of wealth and abundance was the very thing that precipitated Israel's idolatry throughout the rest of the Old Testament, and it is the reason so much of Jesus' teaching and the book of James speak so intensely about the spiritual dangers of riches.

The episode draws a vivid illustration from C.S. Lewis's The Silver Chair, in which Aslan gives Jill Pole four signs to repeat every morning and every evening—an echo of Deuteronomy 6. She forgets, and when a witch tries to convince her that Aslan is not real, she has no defenses. The same pattern threatens anyone who stops rehearsing the story of God's rescue. Without constant repetition, we begin to believe that God is just a projection, that our abundance is self-made, and that we have no need for a deliverer.

Five Reasons to Obey

The episode closes with Deuteronomy 6:23–25, which provides five reasons for obedience. First, because God rescued us. Every command is grounded in the prior reality that God delivered his people out of Egypt before he ever asked anything of them. God's rescue precedes and produces obedience, not the other way around—and this is the thing both Israel and the church are most prone to forget. Second, so that we might properly fear God, maintaining a healthy awareness that his word carries the authority to judge. Third, for our good. God's commands are not oppressive restrictions but the owner's manual for human flourishing. We were not designed for the psychological trauma of murder, the anxiety of deception, or the brokenness of grief. When we obey, we are inviting the goodness of the new creation back into our present experience. Fourth, for our life. These commands lead ultimately to eternal life with God in the new heavens and the new earth, not because we earn our way there but because the life God offers is the life these commands describe. And fifth, for our righteousness. This is not the legal righteousness Jesus earns for us on the cross, nor the inherent righteousness of God himself, but what might be called lived righteousness—the justice and goodness we actually do in the world. God's commands are good news because they mean our efforts matter. The world can actually be changed when the people of God obey the commands of God. His Kingdom comes in part through us.

Transcript

Related Resources

Listen to the Deuteronomy 1-3: Introduction podcast

Listen Now

Listen to the Deuteronomy 4: Why Obey the Law podcast

Listen Now

Listen to the Deuteronomy 5-6: The Ten Commandments (Again?) podcast

Listen Now

Listen to the Deuteronomy 7-9: Chosen People podcast

Listen Now

Listen to the Deuteronomy 10-11: Heart Circumcision podcast

Listen Now

Listen to the Deuteronomy 12-14: Israel's Distinctiveness podcast

Listen Now

Listen to the Deuteronomy 15-16: The Sabbatical Year podcast

Listen Now

Listen to the Deuteronomy 17-18: Judges, Kings, and Prophets podcast

Listen Now

Listen to the Deuteronomy 19-21: Innocent Blood and Holy War podcast

Listen Now

Listen to the Deuteronomy 22-25: Miscellaneous Laws podcast

Listen Now

Listen to the Deuteronomy 26-30: Blessing and Curse podcast

Listen Now

Listen to the Deuteronomy 31-34: Song of Moses podcast

Listen Now
Free videos sent straight to your inbox.